Book a chef near you

Choose your preference:

4 Persons

American as Apple Pie? Not So Fast

Apple Pie_CookinGenie

There are certain things that just evoke America 

 – Baseball. 

– Uncle Sam.  

– Corn fields.  

– Apple pie.  

 

But what if we told you one of these iconic symbols doesn’t really belong on the list? 

 Turns out there’s nothing all that American about apple pie. In fact, neither apples or pie originated in North America: the ancient Egyptians get the credit for creating pie, and modern apples originated in the mountains of Kazakhstan, then spread along the Silk Roads from Central Asia to Europe 

While early pies were made with meatEmily Upton, writing for Today I Found Out, reports that the first recorded apple pie recipe was from England way back in 1381. These early recipes bear little resemblance to the apple pies we know today—they rarely called for sugar (which was an expensive, luxury ingredient at that time) and came served in a pastry that went by the rather unappetizing name of “coffin.” This “coffin” was not meant to be eaten; it was really just a container to hold the filling, sort of the Middle Ages version of a paper plate. The first apple pie recipe that resembles the pie we know and loves today, with a sweetened filling and a lattice top, appeared in a 1514 Dutch cookbook. 

So how did apple pie—which is so deeply rooted in Europe—become synonymous with America? European-style apple trees arrived on American shores with the Jamestown colonists, who brought seeds and cuttings to plant in the New World. (And here’s a fun fact from What’s Cooking America: In Colonial times, apples were sometimes called winter bananas.) As colonists pushed westward, they brought apples with them. Upton credits Johnny Appleseed with cementing the apple as part of American folklore, as he roamed the frontier planting acres upon acres of apple orchards. By the 19th century, American farmers had planted and cross-pollinated trees to develop an astounding 14,000 different varieties of apples. And of course, many of those varieties were perfect for making pie. 

(Also ReadA Whirlwind Tour of US Barbecue)

Nearly as intriguing as the history of the apple in America is the history of the phrase “as American as apple pie. Upton cites a newspaper article in 1902 that said “no pie-eating people can be permanently vanquished” and a 1924 ad in the Gettysburg Times selling “New Lestz Suits that are as American as apple pie.” The phrase became such a part of the American fabric that by World War II, soldiers told journalists that they were fighting for “mom and apple pie.” 

Apple pie may have become a symbol of all that’s good about Americans, but there is a dessert that’s actually a better candidate for the title. While it might not have the same ring, a more apt phrase might be “As American as a blueberry cobbler.” Unlike the apple, blueberries—along with black cherries, strawberries, cranberries, and elderberries—are native to North America, and cobblers are a uniquely American creation. These fruit and pastry desserts, along with regional variations with such colorful names as Bettys, pandowdies, grunts, slumps, buckles, sonkers, crumbles, and crisps were created by early American settlers who turned to the simple ingredients they had on hand to create satisfying desserts. Nevertheless, it’s apple pie that became the apple of Americans’ eyes. 

At CookinGenie, we’ve recently added fresh homemade desserts to our menu and naturally, our choices include an all-American apple pie. Genie Brande Colson folds tart green apples and warm spices into a flaky, golden, homemade crust. She can even make a gluten-free variety. Cap off your next CookinGenie visit with a slice of this wholesome, rustic goodness—we can’t think of a better way to end a home-cooked meal. 

You May Also Like

save more with personal chef

Nov 01, 2021

How Can You Save More by Hiring a Personal Chef?

Let’s do a little exercise really quickly. What’s the first thing you think of when you hear the words “personal chef”? More than likely, you’re thinking something along the lines of how expensive it must be or how...

Read More

Culinary Adventures in Lexington

Oct 03, 2023

Post-Black Friday Culinary Adventures to Enjoy in Lexington

In the wake of Black Friday, as the dust from the shopping frenzy settles, Lexington emerges as a shopper’s paradise and a gastronome’s dream destination. While you might be well-acquainted...

Read More

Halloween night in Cleveland

Aug 19, 2023

How to Celebrate Cleveland’s Spookiest Night

Halloween night is waited for by people worldwide, and Cleveland is no exception. With its haunted history, spooky attractions, and numerous Halloween activities in Cleveland, this activity has become a...

Read More

10 Big Game Party Ideas - CookinGenie

Jan 31, 2022

10 Big Game Party Ideas To Make Your Event Memorable

Whether you tune in for the creative commercials or to see the action on the gridiron, there’s nothing like getting ready for the Big Game. No matter if you’re planning...

Read More

Eating with a Conscience Sustainable Seafood Choices

Feb 24, 2023

Eating with a Conscience: Sustainable Seafood Choices 

Seafood is a delicious and nutritious source of protein, but not all seafood is created equal. In fact, many species are being overfished, causing damage to our oceans and threatening...

Read More

Create The Best Cincinnati Gift Basket

May 30, 2023

Create the Best Cincinnati Gift Basket with Personal Chef Cincinnati

Hey there, gift-giving connoisseur! prepare yourself for an extraordinary adventure through the vibrant streets of Cincinnati. We’re about to take your gifting game to a new level with a gift...

Read More

Tips for Mindful eating

Jan 23, 2023

Eating with Awareness: Mastering the Art of Mindful Eating

Mindful eating is an approach to food that centers on paying attention to the experience of eating and one’s emotions. Mindful eaters know how their environment and sensory stimulation can...

Read More

Jul 15, 2020

What is CookinGenie

What is CookinGenie? CookinGenie is a service where delicious and healthy home-cooked meals come with only a couple of taps on your smartphone. The twist is that the food is...

Read More

Thanksgiving Dinner in Columbus

Dec 08, 2023

Where to Find the Best Thanksgiving Dinner in Columbus?

Thanksgiving, a time for gratitude and togetherness, often comes with its fair share of culinary stress. Not everyone wants to (or can) spend hours in the kitchen, meticulously crafting a...

Read More

Book A Personal Chef

Don't settle for ordinary, elevate your event with a personal chef

You May Also Like

The Benefits of Hiring a Personal Chef for Food Allergies

Aug 11, 2022

The Benefits of Hiring a Personal Chef for Food Allergies

Did you know that food allergies are on the rise? According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, around 12 million Americans have food allergies that account for 50,000...

Read More

Corporate Event in Columbus

Jul 04, 2023

How To Have the Best Corporate Event in Columbus, Ohio

Organizing a successful corporate event can significantly impact your organization’s growth and reputation. When it comes to choosing a location for your next corporate event, there could be no better...

Read More

TV-focused snackers-1

Mar 14, 2023

Snack Culture 2.0: The Intersection of Technology and Food Consumption Among Youth

It’s official: snacks have taken over the world (or at least our stomachs). From the crunch of chips to the sweetness of candy, we’re snacking at all times of the...

Read More

New Years events in Columbus Ohio

Nov 01, 2023

Top 10 Ideas to Celebrate New Year’s Eve Cozily: Columbus’ Stay-At-Home Edition

As the clock winds down and the old year gives way to the new, there’s a unique charm that envelops the city of Columbus. The streets are abuzz with anticipation,...

Read More

Food Tour in Columbus

Sep 15, 2023

How to Do a Food Tour in Columbus, Ohio?

If you’re a food lover or an adventurous eater, embarking on a food tour in Columbus is an absolute must. From local favorites and international cuisines to innovative eateries and...

Read More

7 Things To Do In Cincinnati For Food Lovers

May 26, 2023

7 Things To Do In Cincinnati For Food Lovers

Cincinnati is a vibrant city known for its thriving food scene and offers a delightful array of culinary experiences for food lovers. Whether you’re a local or visiting Cincinnati for...

Read More

Charcuterie - CookinGenie blog

Apr 26, 2021

How to Dazzle Your Dinner Party Guests? A Charcuterie Spread May Be The Answer

Whether it be displayed out at your dinner party, the beginning of date night, or accompanying your favorite bottle of wine, a charcuterie board is a perfect accouterment. Charcuterie (pronounced “shahr–kyut-uh-ree”) is...

Read More

Labor Day in Cincinnati

Aug 16, 2023

How to Celebrate Labor Day Outdoors in Cincinnati?

Labor Day, an annual tribute to the hardworking American workforce, presents an excellent opportunity to immerse yourself in the beauty of the stunning outdoors of Cincinnati. This dynamic city, with...

Read More

Eating with a Conscience Sustainable Seafood Choices

Feb 24, 2023

Eating with a Conscience: Sustainable Seafood Choices 

Seafood is a delicious and nutritious source of protein, but not all seafood is created equal. In fact, many species are being overfished, causing damage to our oceans and threatening...

Read More