3 Creepy Dishes a Private Chef Can Cook Up for You this Halloween in Columbus
Halloween is creeping up, and what better way to celebrate the spooky season than by indulging in some delightfully eerie food? If you’re hosting a Halloween bash in Columbus and want to treat your guests to a meal that’s as thrilling as it is tasty, hire a private chef to whip up some creepy culinary creations.
Forget the boring bowls of candy and ho-hum hors d’oeuvres—this year, it’s all about bringing the fright to the dinner table. Ready to see what’s on the menu? Let’s dive into three spine-chilling dishes that will make your Halloween in Columbus, Ohio, the talk of the town!
Ghost Pizza with Olive Spiders
First up is a treat that will give you chills down your spine and have your taste buds screaming for more: Ghost Pizza with Olive Spiders. The ghost pizza will have a proper mix of eerie looks and mouthwatering flavors, making it the highlight of your Halloween activities in Columbus, Ohio.
Why this dish?
- It works for the perfected pizza maker or the easy store-bought dough kind of person. It’s all about presentation, not perfection, so don’t freak out over everything being perfect; after all, it’s Halloween in Columbus, Ohio.
- This pizza with mozzarella and black olives in a cute ghost shape is fun and will make your guests’ faces grin like jack-o’-lanterns. The rosemary sprigs pulling double duty as spider legs are an extra clever, savory touch.
- Want to add more ghoulish toppings? Have at it! From pepperoni pumpkins to mushroom mummies to bell pepper bats, the possibilities for making this yours are endless.
Preparation
The private chef will make this spooky pizza on a crust smeared with rich tomato sauce and topped with olive spiders that are crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. After quick baking in the oven, they’ll add ghostly mozzarella shapes melting into gooey perfection. The final touch? A sprinkle of chopped olives for the ghost eyes. One bite and you are in pizza heaven—or maybe purgatory; you’ll know when you taste.
Witch Finger Cookies
Next on the menu is something that will both delight and disturb your guests—Witch Finger Cookies. These creepy cookies look eerily realistic, and they’re guaranteed to be a showstopper at your Halloween gathering.
Why this dish?
- Nothing says Halloween quite like a dessert that’s designed to make your skin crawl. These witch finger cookies are disturbingly realistic, with knobby knuckles, almond nails, and bloody jam oozing from the tips.
- Don’t let their grotesque appearance fool you—these cookies are as tasty as they are terrifying. The shortbread base is buttery and sweet, with a hint of almond flavor that perfectly complements the gory cherry jam.
- Want to involve your guests? Have them help with the cookie decoration! There’s something delightfully wicked about shaping the dough into creepy fingers and adding the finishing touches to make them look just right.
Read more: Best kid friendly Halloween events in Columbus, Ohio
Preparation
These finger-shaped shortbread cookies are dyed a sickly shade of green, rolled and pinched into knobby, bony shapes, and topped with slivered almonds to create the perfect witch’s manicure. After baking, your chef will add a dollop of red cherry jam to the tips, making it look like the fingers were freshly severed (gross but delicious!).
These cookies are a fun way to end your meal and make for a gruesomely good centerpiece on your dessert table. Just be prepared for your guests to hesitate before biting—these fingers look almost too real.
Vampire Mouth Marshmallow Sandwich Cookies
And last but most definitely not least, we have one treat about the bite: Vampire Mouth Marshmallow Sandwich Cookies. These creepy creations are so much fun yet outstanding; they’ll make a great addition to your Halloween in Columbus, Ohio.
Why this dish?
- Who doesn’t love s’mores? But these vampire mouth cookies take the classic treat in a completely different and much scarier direction. How could the combination of chocolate graham cookies, tangy cream cheese frosting, and puffed marshmallows go together any other way but a match made in Halloween heaven?
- Terrifyingly tasty indeed, these cookies’ red frosting and almond fangs give them quite the look from a horror movie, but the flavor mix sure isn’t. This chunk of sweet, tangy, and chocolatey goodness will keep them wanting more.
- Half the fun of Halloween food is how it looks. These cookies must be photographed and shared on social media, so prepare for some serious Instagram love.
Read More: What are some great unique experiences in Columbus, Ohio?
Preparation
Your private chef will prepare these vampire mouth cookies, starting with homemade chocolate graham crackers rolled and cut into rounds. Bake, then slice the cookies in half and spread thickly with a blood-red cream cheese frosting. Mini marshmallows are set against the curved edge to form ‘teeth,’ and slivered almonds are added as fangs. The result? A deliciously devilish cookie. Serve these with a glass of “blood” (aka red punch), and you’ve got a fang-tastic finale to your Halloween feast.
A Halloween Feast to Die For
There you have it: three creepy creative dishes that assuredly make your Columbus Halloween dinner one to remember. And because a private chef in Columbus, Ohio, does the work, you can enjoy the festivities while they do their magic in making those spooky culinary visions come true.
And the best part? Each of these recipes can be made to suit your tastes so that your Halloween menu is as unique as your party. So go ahead—take a bite of the eerie, indulge in the creepy, and let your private chef cook up a meal to die for!