Sabah Drabu

4 mins read

Jul 31, 2023


5 Reasons to Not Choose Catering for Thanksgiving in Columbus

As the autumn breeze gently sweeps through the streets of Columbus, the anticipation for Thanksgiving builds. It’s that time of the year when the city comes alive with the spirit of gratitude, camaraderie, and, of course, the allure of a delectable Thanksgiving feast. Many contemplate making this year’s celebration extra special as the holiday draws near.

Thanksgiving catering may seem like the perfect solution – offering a tempting array of pre-prepared dishes that promise to relieve you of the kitchen chaos. But before you decide, we urge you to pause and consider the essence of this cherished holiday. Beyond the convenience, there are compelling reasons why Columbus, Ohio, Thanksgiving catering might not be the best option for you.

In this blog, we delve into the five reasons to forgo catering and explore alternatives to make your Thanksgiving an exceptional and unforgettable affair. From preserving family traditions to savoring the flavors of homemade dishes, we unravel the magic when the feast is prepared with love and care in the heart of your home.

  1. Lack of Personalization

Thanksgiving is when families come together to celebrate and create lasting memories. Unfortunately, choosing catering for this special occasion can result in a lack of personalization. Catering menus are often pre-designed with limited options, leaving little room for customization. Family recipes and unique dishes that hold sentimental value might be absent from a catered meal, depriving loved ones of the tastes and flavors that evoke cherished memories.

The essence of Thanksgiving lies in the warmth of sharing homemade dishes prepared with love and care. Cooking allows families to personalize their menu, incorporating special ingredients and adjusting recipes to cater to individual preferences. Cooking together promotes bonding and strengthens family ties, making Thanksgiving a memorable experience.

  1. Quality and Freshness Concerns

While catering might promise convenience, it can compromise the quality and freshness of the food. Mass production often sacrifices quality, as caterers focus on quantity over individual attention to each dish. The risk of pre-cooked or frozen meals being served is high, dampening the joy of savoring a freshly prepared Thanksgiving feast.

On the other hand, cooking at home allows control over the quality of ingredients. Home-cooked meals can be made with fresh, locally sourced produce, ensuring a superior taste and nutritional value. By taking the time to handpick ingredients, families can indulge in the pleasure of a delicious, wholesome meal.

Limited Dietary Options

In today’s diverse dietary landscape, catering may only cater to some people’s needs and demands. Those with specific dietary restrictions or food allergies may find their options severely limited, leading to a less enjoyable experience. Cross-contamination is a common concern with catering, as multiple dishes are prepared in the same kitchen.

Cooking Thanksgiving dinner at home allows for the customization of each dish to accommodate various dietary preferences. Families can easily prepare vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, or other specialty dishes to ensure everyone feels included and valued during the celebration. Adapting recipes empowers hosts to create a diverse and inclusive menu that meets their guests’ needs.

  1. Cost Considerations

Though catering may appear convenient, it often comes with a hefty price tag. The cost of Thanksgiving catering services in Columbus and potential hidden fees and delivery charges can significantly inflate the overall expense. Additionally, the lack of control over portion sizes may lead to excess food and unnecessary waste.

In contrast, cooking Thanksgiving dinner at home can be a cost-effective alternative. Shopping for ingredients at local stores or markets allows for budget management, and leftovers can be creatively utilized for post-Thanksgiving meals. The satisfaction of preparing a home-cooked meal, knowing the effort and love poured into it, adds immeasurable value to the overall experience.

  1. Family Bonding and Traditions

Thanksgiving is more than just a sumptuous meal; it’s a time for family bonding and cherished traditions. When choosing catering, families miss out on the opportunity to come together in the kitchen, sharing the joy of meal preparation. The laughter, conversations, and occasional culinary mishaps create lasting memories and reinforce family bonds.

Cooking together fosters teamwork, communication, and a sense of accomplishment as loved ones contribute to the meal’s creation. Family recipes passed down through generations gain new life, keeping traditions alive for years. The sense of togetherness from preparing and enjoying a home-cooked Thanksgiving dinner makes the occasion special and unforgettable.

  1. Local Community Support

Thanksgiving is an excellent time to support local businesses and farms, contributing to the community’s growth. Opting for Thanksgiving catering in Columbus might mean sourcing ingredients from far-off suppliers, bypassing the chance to bolster local economies. In contrast, shopping locally for fresh produce ensures higher quality and better taste and supports local farmers and businesses.

By selecting locally sourced ingredients, families can discover the unique flavors and culinary delights that Columbus offers. The sense of connection to the community enhances the Thanksgiving experience, knowing that the meal results from collective effort and shared prosperity.

CookinGenie – A Solution

Thanksgiving in Columbus offers many dining choices, but when creating a truly exceptional experience, CookinGenie stands as an enticing solution. Embracing the essence of tradition and the convenience of modern technology, CookinGenie introduces a novel approach to elevate your Thanksgiving feast.

Discover the Magic of CookinGenie: CookinGenie brings a touch of culinary magic to your holiday celebration by connecting you with skilled personal chefs in Columbus. With CookinGenie, you can collaborate with these talented chefs to curate a bespoke Thanksgiving menu that caters to your family’s unique preferences and dietary needs.

A Personalized Culinary Experience: Say goodbye to generic catering menus and embrace a personalized culinary journey with CookinGenie. Discuss your favorite dishes, dietary restrictions, and any special requests directly with the chef. Witness as your kitchen transforms into a gourmet haven, where your chosen chef prepares the feast of a lifetime with skill and passion.

Supporting Local Talent and Fresh Ingredients: CookinGenie enriches your dining experience and fosters support for local communities in Columbus. By choosing CookinGenie, you contribute to the growth of talented local chefs and help sustain nearby suppliers and farms. Your Thanksgiving meal will be crafted using the freshest and finest ingredients, adding a touch of local flair to your dining table.

Elevate Your Thanksgiving Experience: CookinGenie unlocks a world of culinary possibilities that go beyond the confines of conventional catering. Whether you’re seeking a traditional Thanksgiving spread or a fusion of diverse flavors, CookinGenie can turn your vision into reality.


As you plan your Thanksgiving celebration in Columbus, let CookinGenie be the gateway to an unparalleled dining experience. Enjoy the convenience of professional assistance combined with the intimacy and personalization of a home-cooked meal. Embrace the joy of sharing a bespoke feast with your loved ones and create memories that will last a lifetime. Elevate your Thanksgiving with CookinGenie this year and relish in the magic of a tailor-made, chef-prepared masterpiece. Happy Thanksgiving!

Sabah Drabu

Co-Founder & CEO

Sabah Drabu is a foodie, engineer, and the Co-founder & CEO of CookinGenie. She created the platform in 2019 to connect local chefs with at-home diners, making hiring personal chefs more accessible. Sabah's idea has evolved into a service people use for parties, vacation rentals, and family gatherings.

More Posts
Easter brunch in Columbus
Baby Shower in Columbus
Seasonal Events in Columbus